|
PUBLICATION:
|
The Hamilton
Spectator |
|
DATE:
|
2005.06.07 |
|
EDITION:
|
Final |
|
SECTION:
|
Local |
|
PAGE:
|
A2 |
|
COLUMN:
|
Bill Dunphy |
|
BYLINE:
|
Bill Dunphy |
|
SOURCE:
|
The Hamilton
Spectator |
|
ILLUSTRATION: |
Photo: John
Walker, shown in a 1965 photo, blames his diabetes on
exposure to Agent Orange while he was stationed in Gagetown
with the Black Watch regiment. |
Is Agent Orange
killing Canadian veterans?
John Walker leafs
through his yellowing photo album, flip- ping page after page,
pointing to the black-and-white photos of the young soldiers,
beaming with good health and vigour.
"These guys -- they
were all exposed to it. They are all infected, but do they know
that?"
Infection may be the
wrong word. But exposed isn't.
Walker is talking
about being exposed to Agent Orange, the notorious toxic defoliant
sprayed on Vietnamese jungles in mind-numbing quantities by the
Americans during their war. Agent Orange created a horrific legacy
of disease, cancers, and miscarriages, which scars that country's
people to this day.
So toxic was Agent
Orange that tens of thousands of Americans have fallen gravely ill
or died as a result of exposure to the chemical during the war.
What few Canadians
realize is that Agent Orange was used and tested here in Canada at
the Armed Forces Gagetown base in New Brunswick and that hundreds,
if not thousands, of Canadian soldiers and support staff were
exposed to it.
Many may be sick,
dying or dead as a result.
Walker fears he too
has fallen ill -- with adult onset diabetes -- because of his years
at Gagetown, where he served as a private in the 2nd Battalion of
the Black Watch Regiment.
"I remember one time
in 1967 we were training and had pulled into a copse of trees for
the night, a section of forest maybe one mile thick by two or three
miles long.
"There were no leaves
on the trees, no grass on the ground. It was all just dead.
"You pull in, you're
digging slit trenches -- six feet deep, two feet wide - - you're
covered in this (crap) and you're sleeping in it. And then you bring
it all home and your wife washes your clothes ..."
His voice trails off.
He's lost touch with his ex-wife and their two daughters, but he
wonders if they too may have been affected.
Walker comes from a
Dundas military family and back in 1965, still in his teens, he
signed on with the Black Watch. Over the next four
years he would spend about 21 months or so stationed at Gagetown,
where in 1966 Canadian authorities invited Americans to test Agent
Orange on swaths of the base's hardwood forest and scrub brush.
Although the tests
were no secret at the time, they weren't acknowledged by the armed
forces until the early '80s and then it was only to reassure the
public that there had been no ecological harm done.
Until very recently,
they insisted there were no health problems associated with the
spraying and rejected all requests for compensation from sick -- and
in some cases dying -- veterans.
It's important to note
that establishing direct causal links between environmental toxins
and cancers or diseases that turn up decades later in specific
individuals is very tricky science. But in the U.S. authorities
became so convinced about the overall association between Agent
Orange exposure and a list of 11 or so cancers and diseases that
they have for years extended disability pensions to any soldier who
had those diseases and might have been exposed to the chemical.
Canada is years behind
that standard.
But after decades of
denial, late last year they quietly approved two disability pensions
related to Agent Orange exposure, one from exposure in Vietnam
(during peacekeeping duties) and one at Gagetown.
The story only leaked
out last month.
And now, like a slowly
burning fuse connecting a long string of firecrackers, it's blowing
up in community after community across the country as word gets out.
Walker was stunned
when he saw the press coverage and realized it may explain his
health problems, his now barely controlled diabetes and the
associated neuropathy in his legs.
Discovering that it
could have been caused by a callous exposure during his service to
his country hit him hard.
"It's like the stages
of grief. The first week I couldn't even talk about it, this week
I'm angry -- God knows what I'll be like next week."
He's applied for a
disability pension and been told he'll get an answer within four to
six months.
He says he hasn't been
able to work since December and is down to his last $700 of his
savings. He wonders how many cases like him are out there.
"How many thousands of
soldiers were stationed there during those years?" Walker asks. And
how many have fallen prey to diseases linked to, or associated with,
exposure to Agent Orange?
The short answer is,
no one knows.
Janice Sommerby, of
Veterans Affairs, said yesterday that in the previous five years
since her department began tracking disability pension requests
linked to Agent Orange exposure, 25 people have applied.
(Twenty-three have been turned down.) In the four weeks since the
story broke, they've had 200 calls inquiring about disability
pensions linked to Agent Orange.
Are Walker's illnesses
caused by Agent Orange? Does he deserve a disability pension?
I don't have a clue.
But I know he and
many, many other of our vets deserve much better treatment than
they're getting so far.
bdunphy@thespec.com
905-526-3262
